Website audit · 15 June 2026
Selvaggio Lawyers
selvaggiolawyers.com.auPoor · professional services
A competent but forgettable law firm website that blends into the crowd and leaves AI assistants with almost nothing to cite.
Selvaggio Lawyers has a clean, navigable site with solid service breadth and named specialists — but the homepage copy is generic, the structured data is skeletal, and there is no social proof, pricing context, or differentiation that would compel a visitor or an AI to choose them over any other suburban Sydney law firm. The site ranks for its own brand name but shows no signals of authority beyond that.
The breakdown · 7 dimensions, worst first
AI & LLM Visibility
38The existing JSON-LD is limited to WebPage, WebSite, and BreadcrumbList — there is no Attorney, LegalService, LocalBusiness, or Person schema for Ross Selvaggio or Gillian Leahy, despite both being named Law Society accredited specialists. An AI assistant asked 'who are the best property lawyers in Norwest Sydney?' has almost no structured signals to cite this firm confidently. The homepage copy does name the lawyers and their accreditations inline, which provides some entity clarity, but there are no FAQ schema blocks, no review schema, no service area definitions, and no authoritative external citations visible. The FAQs & Guides section exists as a navigation item but its content was not scraped — if it contains structured Q&A, that would help, but it is not reflected in the homepage schema.
Messaging & Copy
48The copy across all service tabs is descriptive rather than persuasive — it explains what the firm does, not what the client gets or feels. Phrases like 'disputes are sometimes avoidable' (under Litigation) appear to be typos for 'unavoidable', undermining credibility. The Family Law section uses 'Selvaggio Family Lawyers' as if it were a separate brand, creating inconsistency. There are no client outcome statements, no mention of years in practice, no fee transparency, and no urgency triggers for time-sensitive matters like unfair dismissal (mentioned in Employment copy but not acted upon with a CTA). The meta description is serviceable but generic.
Conversion
52The phone number (02 9899 9677) is visible in the header and the contact page is accessible from the main nav — these are positives. However, the homepage has only two CTAs ('Our Services' and 'Contact Us') and neither is repeated after the hero section or within any of the six service tab descriptions. The 'Learn More' links within tabs are H6-styled and visually subordinate. There is no free consultation offer, no callback form embedded on the homepage, no live chat, and no urgency messaging for time-sensitive matters. The contact page (visible in Google results) shows a full address and email, which is good, but the homepage itself does not surface enough conversion hooks for visitors who don't scroll to the footer.
Design & Brand
55The heading hierarchy moves from H1 (page title) to H4s for service area headings and H6s for 'Learn More' links — skipping H2 and H3 almost entirely on the homepage, which weakens both visual hierarchy and semantic structure. Service images have descriptive alt text (e.g. 'Selvaggio Lawyers - Property & Commercial') which is adequate but formulaic. There is a typo in the scraped content ('Litigation & Dispiutes') in a tab label, suggesting QA gaps. The SVG logo is present and linked correctly. Overall the brand feels functional but undifferentiated — no tagline, no colour-coded practice areas, no visual personality.
Trust & Authority
56The site names two Law Society of NSW accredited specialists in Property Law (Ross Selvaggio and Gillian Leahy), which is a genuine and meaningful trust signal — but it is buried in a tab panel rather than featured prominently. Ross Selvaggio's 1981 graduation date (visible in Google results for his profile page) implies 40+ years of experience, which is never stated on the homepage. There are no Google review counts, star ratings, testimonials, case outcomes, or client logos visible in the scraped homepage content. The Facebook and LinkedIn social links are present in the header. The news section shows a 2023 article, indicating some recency, but the overall trust architecture is thin for a firm competing in a market where clients are making high-stakes decisions.
SEO Foundations
57The page title 'Selvaggio Lawyers - Family Law, Commercial Law & Property Law, Sydney' and meta description are present and keyword-relevant. The site ranks in position 3 for its own brand name, with the About Us page appearing above the homepage — a mild cannibalisation signal. The structured data contains only WebPage, BreadcrumbList, and WebSite types with no LegalService, LocalBusiness, Attorney, or Person schema, which is a significant missed opportunity. The dateModified is February 2023, suggesting the site has not been updated in over a year. Internal linking is extensive via the mega-menu but the homepage body content has no keyword-rich anchor text linking to service pages beyond tab navigation.
First Impression
58The H1 'Property, Commercial and Family Lawyers in Norwest, Sydney' is clear and location-specific, which is good for local intent. However, the supporting line — 'offers the expertise and wealth of experience you would normally find in a CBD practice' — is a tired, defensive comparison that immediately positions the firm as second-best to city firms. The two CTAs ('Our Services' and 'Contact Us') are present but the primary CTA anchors to a same-page section rather than a conversion action. There is no hero statement of outcomes, urgency, or emotional resonance for someone in a stressful legal situation.
We found 12 specific fixes for selvaggiolawyers.com.au
The problems are above. The fixes are ready.
This page shows what's broken. We've already mapped exactly how to fix every issue — the rewrites, the schema, the structure, in priority order. Want the full fix list for selvaggiolawyers.com.au?
Get the fix list →Free · delivered by Optimize Labs
Want this for your own site? Run a free audit →